Never Miss a Headline!

Dilshan's dubious dismissal reignites referral system debate

Updated On: 03 December, 2009 07:49 AM IST | Sanjjeev K Samyal

It is ironic that when the rest of the cricket world is using the Umpire Decision Review System (UDRS), a gaping umpiring blunder cut short a brilliant innings during the third Test between India and Sri Lanka at the Brabourne Stadium yesterday.

It is ironic that when the rest of the cricket world is using the Umpire Decision Review System (UDRS), a gaping umpiring blunder cut short a brilliant innings during the third Test between India and Sri Lanka at the Brabourne Stadium yesterday.

Sri Lanka opener Tillakaratne Dilshan received a shocker by umpire Nigel Llong when he adjudged him caught at short-leg off glove and pad when the glove was nearly a foot away from the ball. Dilshan scored 109.

The Review System is being used in all the other ongoing international series, including Australia-West Indies, New Zealand-Pakistan and South Africa-England. India's series against Sri Lanka is the only exception to this rule and it is believed that this is mainly due to the reluctance of the hosts. The official reason provided though is that the broadcaster is not ready to bear the extra cost of the equipment required, like the hot spot and hawk eye.

It is known that the Lankans were keen on employing the UDRS in this series. Sri Lanka's team manager Brendon Kuruppu refused to comment on Dilshan's decision, but diplomatically said enough to show his team's resentment.

"It (referral system) is fair to both teams. It increases the confidence of the players when they know that they won't be victims of error in judgement," Kuruppu told MiD DAY.

"At first we were under the impression that it would be used in this series after the ICC made it mandatory from October 1, but then there was some confusion and the ICC left it to the respective boards."

The Indian team had a taste of the system during the away Test series against Lanka with the host spinners winning most of the decisions. However, Kuruppu felt the referral system was a success.

When asked if the UDRS was an advantage for the bowlers, especially the unorthodox ones like Muttiah Muralitharan, who are difficult to read, Kuruppu said: "Bowlers have benefitted on most occasions but batsmen have appealed successfully too."

A case in point is Dilshan's ouster. "I'd be still batting (if there was a review)," Dilshan said.

All said and done, yesterday's umpiring blunder has only highlighted the significance of technology in decision-making.

Trending Stories

Skand Thakur: We have to prove ourselves even for a one-minute role

India thrash Japan 5-1 in Asian Champions Trophy

"The rise of ...": Khawaja feels this has boosted Australia to defeat India

Murali worried about Test cricket’s future

"The kind of cricket Bangladesh have played is impressive": Shubman Gill

Apple iPhone 16 launch: Know the features, prices and availability in India

Up and about: Bye bye Bappa!

Have you heard? Powerful combo

Latest Web Stories

Kim Kardashian turns into a soccer mom

1 years ago

5 reasons Sargun Mehta is a boss lady!

1 years ago

Aadar and Alekha's loved-up pics

1 years ago

Ananya Panday with her late dog Fudge

1 years ago

Latest Photos

17 December, 2025 11:56 AM IST | IN PHOTOS: MLAs at Vidhan Bhavan during Maharashtra Legislative Council polls

Asif Ali Sayed

09 September, 2024 09:32 PM IST | IN PHOTOS: People in Mumbai celebrate Gauri Puja during Ganeshotsav

Asif Ali Sayed

09 September, 2024 09:13 PM IST | IN PHOTOS: Mumbai witnesses sunny weather as rains take a break

Asif Ali Sayed

09 September, 2024 01:53 PM IST | In Photos: Amit Shah attends Ganeshotsav 2024 festivities in Mumbai

Divya Nair

Latest Videos

Putin's BLOODIEST Kyiv Blitz | 27 Dead, 52,000 In Bunkers As Zelenskyy Swears Revenge | WATCH

Iran's 5-day State FUNERAL For Ayatollah Ali Khamenei | 100 Nations Arrive For Historic Farewell

Israel Plot To KILL Iran's Negotiators? US Feared Secret Strike Could Trigger All-out War | WATCH

Syria Cafe Blast: Bomb EXPLODES Inside Cafe Killing 5 in Damascus, Syria Launches Investigation

Mumbai Rains HORROR: 55-year-old FALLS Into Open Manhole in Sakinaka, Dies; BMC Suspends Four

Mid-day Fast

Entertainment

dsadsdsadsd

Entertainment

Deepika & Ranveer's daughter is boon to her parents, predicts astrologer

Lifestyle

The art of accessorising traditional attire for Ganesh Chaturthi

Latest Headlines

Kindly mail us your feedback

Follow Us:

Home

Photos

E-Paper

Videos

MD Fast