At its third hearing on Monday, the commission closed the suo motu case considering the solemn affidavit on oath submitted by Subrao Narayan Shinde, joint secretary in the Urban Development Department (UDD), on behalf of the chief secretary.

Shinde said the Home Department, on UDD’s request, has also directed the Navi Mumbai police commissioner to provide adequate protection for the demolition. 

Poll

How are rising Ganesh idol prices affecting the traditional celebrations for Ganesh Chaturthi in Mumbai?

Higher costs for devotees 40.78%

Impact on mandal activities 28.25%

Shift to alternative celebrations 30.97%

Submit

View All In Poll

NGO NatConnect Foundation, which launched an awareness campaign and filed three affidavits at the commission, pointed out that the soil on the hills is loose and hence the hills are landslide prone. NatConnect director B N Kumar highlighted the Wayanad and Irshalwadi disaster as hundreds of people congregate at these religious structures, some of which are built on the hill slopes.

He argued that some structures occupying over 20,000 sq ft to 40,000 sq ft have built halls to accommodate up to 2,000 people, which is highly risky.

“The festival season has begun, and devotees are bound to visit the temples. We fear their lives will be at stake. Moreover, there are over 600 houses below the Belapur hill,” Kumar said.

The issue has persisted for nearly a decade since the Kalpataru Cooperative Housing Society first filed a complaint with CIDCO. Now, CIDCO has been directed to take action in line with the Supreme Court's ruling on illegal religious structures. MSHRC, comprising of Justice K K Tated and member M A Sayeed, stated that NatConnect is free to return to the rights body in case of future violations.

According to the NGO NatConnect Foundation, when CIDCO’s counsel attempted to make a statement, Justice Tated said, “The entire case arose due to CIDCO’s inaction. What is there for you to say now?” He then directed both CIDCO and NMMC to comply with the government’s directive.

Kumar noted that CIDCO began the demolition process by razing a compound wall and stairs of a religious structure but halted due to concerns over potential landslides
“CIDCO’s controller of unauthorised constructions brought in two JCB machines, but work was halted due to heavy rain. Weather permitting, the demolition will resume with police protection,” an official said.

The commission also dismissed intervention applications from a charitable trust occupying 1,200 sq ft and another occupying 250 sq ft, both of which pleaded for protection while their regularisation applications were pending.

CIDCO had served demolition notices to these trusts and other unauthorised structures.

2.3 l sq ft
Area covered by these religious structures