“I have been doing business at this spot since the past 20 years. I pay the rent for the shop to run my juice centre. The BMC gave my landowner six options for relocation, but none of them are appropriate for business. This will hamper not just my livelihood, but of my two workers, too,” said Satyanarayan Gupta, owner of JMD juice centre.

A board declaring the private ownership of the land

Poll

Do you agree with the management`s decision of only letting devotees offer jal abhishek at Babulnath temple?

Yes 33.43%

No 33.29%

Maybe 33.29%

Submit

View All In Poll

“The third generation of our family is running the business here. A couple of years ago, a few shops were demolished and the shop owners were given an alternative spot near Mulund Fire Brigade, but they didn’t shift. We have been given a place near Johnson and Johnson, ACC Factory, where there is hardly any crowd,” Rinku Pandey, owner of Khiladi pan bhandar.

Also read: Maharashtra: Small cabinet struggling to keep up with budget session

What was the hurdle?

The BMC had been planning to demolish the shops for a long time, but one Surendra Subhedar Singh has claimed ownership of the land on which the 17 structures are built. He even approached the courts. 

The BMC had last year issued him notice under Section 314 of the Mumbai Municipal Corporation (MMC) Act, 1888 for the removal of the “unauthorised structures on civic lands”. However, Singh contested, saying that his ancestor Jamadar Singh Gokul Singh had constructed the 17 stalls in Mulund West and now he has been collecting rent from them.

Court orders

The civic body got the permission to tear down the shops when the Bombay High Court, on February 16, dismissed Singh’s appeal against a civic court order. On January 23, the civic court rejected his plea to restrain the BMC from demolishing the shops.

The 17 shops are at the junction of JSD Road, where SVP Road connects. Pics/Rajesh Gupta

Advocates Dharmesh Vyas and Smita Tondwalkar, appearing for the BMC in court, however, had said that the land belonged to the civic body and Singh had no documentary evidence to show that he or any of his predecessors owned it, and if any permissions were taken for constructing the stalls.

They told the court that the land is required for the widening of JSD Road and for setting up a drainage system to prevent water logging in the station area during monsoon. The HC had observed that the civil court’s order was well reasoned and it had taken into consideration all the relevant documents.

‘It belongs to my ancestors’

“The land, measuring 175 square metre, belongs to my ancestors from 1949. We have been paying taxes for this non-agricultural plot. Suddenly, the BMC cancelled our property card and told us that we are not the owner. We have filed one more suit in civil court and it will be heard on March 13,” Singh said.

Chakrapani Alle, assistant municipal commissioner, T ward, said, “After receiving the high court order, we gave the stall owners six alternative options to relocate, but there is no decision yet. However, we issued notices to the stall owners on Saturday, February 25, asking them to vacate in 48 hours.”

“The area is crucial for us as far as traffic and different projects are concerned. Once this demolition occurs, we will go ahead and demolish the rest of the stalls on SVP Road,” he added.