Govinda

Rating: 8/10
Judging: 'Dance India Dance Super Moms' (season 2)
In all fairness: Known for his typical dance moves and facial gymnastics, the star was apt to judge this show which had non-celebrity mothers grooving to various kinds of music. Govinda did fairly well as a judge and was also quite responsive to the participants' emotions. His presence definitely helped the show garner better TRPs than what it did in its previous season.

Shahid Kapoor

Rating: 7/10
Judging: 'Jhalak Dikhhla Jaa Reloaded' (season 8)
In all fairness: Being one of the finest dancers in the film industry, the actor was just ideal to judge the celeb-based dance reality show. He replaced dancing diva Madhuri Dixit, who had been a judge for Jhalak for three seasons. While Shahid's opening act was a visual treat, he keeps flaunting his moves off and on during the show. He, however, could not add much spice to Jhalak and ended up shedding tears in his very first episode.

Poll

Who will win the Punjab Elections?

BJP 32.86%

AAP 41.43%

INC 25.71%

Submit

View All In Poll

Lisa Haydon

Rating: 8/10
Judging: 'India's Next Top Model'
In all fairness: The model-turned-actress has been doing a pretty commendable job instilling confidence in aspiring models. She is calm and composed, and politely puts forward her point of view with ease. Lisa does justice to her comparisons with Hollywood beauty Tyra Banks, maker-cum-judge of the original show, America's Next Top Model.

Esha Deol

Rating: 7/10
Judging: 'Roadies' (season 8)
In all fairness: She has been quite on the mark and strict about choosing contestants for the adventure-based reality show. But she did not match up to original judge Raghu Ram's signature cussing-laden grilling during auditions — this was much to the respite of the wannabe roadies and disappointment of viewers.

Preity Zinta

Rating: 6/10
Judging: 'Nach Baliye' (season 7)
In all fairness: After Ekta Kapoor's production house took over this show, she got a new judging panel for the celebrity couple dance reality show. Along with writer Chetan Bhagat and choreographer Marzi Pestonji, Preity was taken on board to add star value to the show. Though the actress barely went wrong with her comments, her involvement did only so much for the show's middling TRP rating.

Lauren Gottlieb

Rating: 6/10
Judging: 'Jhalak Dikhhla Jaa Reloaded' (season 8)
In all fairness: The So You Think You Can Dance finalist from the US, who danced her way into the audience's hearts with her fluid movements on the show's sixth season, was seen in dance drama ABCD2. Being the only woman on an all-male judging panel for the show's current season, she was expected to not just raise the glamour quotient but also give her expert opinion on a participant's strengths and weaknesses. So far, she has been quite good and has overcome her language handicap, but there is always scope for improvement.